Adobe Drops the Ball on ePub

Much has been written in the past year about publishers responses to the Ebook revolution. Little has been written, in comparison, of the software developers behind the books. A case in point is Adobe. Anyone with a web or publishing background looking for a good software program to make digital books, would quite naturally take a look at Adobe.

Adobe, after all, makes Dreamweaver, Photoshop, Illustrator, InDesign, and a few other useful programs for producing digital content. With both a web and publishing background myself, and normally quite a fan of Adobe products, they were my first choice when I decided to try making my first ebook using the epub file format. (Note: epub is the format used by Apple, Kobo, and most other ebook readers with the exception of Amazon’s Kindle.)

For epub’s, Adobe’s go-to product is InDesign CS5. “Create compelling eBooks in the EPUB format for the Apple iPad, Sony Reader, Barnes & Noble nook, mobile phones, and other devices,” their website reads.  For $699, it would seem like solid choice. InDesign has always been a great program for making multi-page documents, like magazines and books. I downloaded the free 30-day trial, with the intention of purchasing the product. Already familiar with InDesign, I figured the leap from pdf to epub should be a short hop, right?

Not exactly.

InDesign treats the ePub format like it was an after-thought. An “.indd” file (InDesign’s native format) must be completely reformatted before making an readable ePub book. Even then, it seems to be a crap shoot if the file is going to work or not. After three weeks working part-time for more than 40 hours on a small 120-page book, browsing forums, reading help files and support articles, I was never able to get my ebook into a format that was acceptable for upload to Apple, or was formatted properly on my Kobo eReader.

So I downloaded two shareware programs: Calibre and Sigil, both of which were referenced in just about every non-Adobe forum I browsed. I dumped a text document into Calibre, and converted it to an epub file. I then opened that file with Sigil, edited it, uploaded a graphic for the cover, created a table of contents and… completed the project in all of two hours.

Converting the epub into a Kindle-accessible format took an extra mouse click.

  • Share/Bookmark
  • Thanks for your insights ... I was considering upgrading to CS-5. I have CS-3 and supposedly there's a way to convert, but I too had nothing but trouble. I look forward to the day when Adobe and Apple get over themselves and begin speaking again.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: